Posted by: chandni | May 17, 2008

The dreaded monthly phenomenon

Check out two radically different perspectives - One by The Mad Momma and one from Lavs.

I am amazed to hear about the fanfare that follows the arrival of a girl’s first period in some communities. Simply because I don’t know of anyone who’s “fertility” has been celebrated this way.

My earliest memories regarding chums is either the sad jokes we cracked when “period” got a new meaning and we made fun of teachers who referred to a class as a period or the embarrassment when close guy friends asked us to explain the sanitary napkin ads and “what is it used for??”

At our place, starting your menstrual cycle meant just that. Another indication of growth, of moving to adulthood. Since I have an older sister, I was pretty much in the know of what was to come. There was no fuss, it just happened one day and that was that. Business as usual.

Even though in my family, none of the religious customs are followed in terms of isolation or not cooking or staying out of the temple…I have pretty much suffered at the hands of others who wanted to push their opinions on us. When I was 10, we visited Puri and went to the Jaggannath temple. Among other things  that those awful priests ate our brain about, they also asked if I had started menstruating. I think my mom was more shocked than me…and he proceeded to tell her that he could do a “pooja” to ensure they come quickly, of course at the cost of some eleven thousand rupees. My mom just told him that I was still young and it will happen when it has to happen, and we were fine without his help. At another stage, we were also asked if any of us women were chumming as in that case, we were better off staying out of the temple. We wouldn’t be allowed.

A friend told me that when she was in school, which was a convent, one of the nuns made the sign of the cross every time she passed a girl who was chumming…

Most interesting experiences took place when I used to take sex education classes for teenagers and guess what, more often than not the boys were more sensible about it than girls.

Looking at opinions, it seems to me either its like a disease, where you need to keep your trap shut and make sure no one even gets to know what’s going on, or you celebrate its arrival and scream it out to the whole world…isn’t it bizzare?

The menstrual cycle is related to one’s ability to perform reproduction, so yes, it is related to fertility. The “cleansing” as we call it, is not because it is “impure”, but simply because unless fertilization happens, at the end of the cycle, its a waste and the body has no need of it. Hence, if one was to get pregnant, it is this material that forms a “bed” for the embryo and provides nutrition to it. If not, out it goes. And that is about it.

But myths feed on what is perpetuated and in no time you find people telling you that it is believed that pickles will go bad if you touch them, religious spaces will be violated if you enter, and that you need to eat in separate utensils and not cook…

Whatever the reasons might have been for it in the older times, they are not valid now. Some women need to rest because it is draining for them, and some just breeze through it…There is nothing more to it.

I always found it strange that a lot of people thought it embarassing to go ask for sanitary towels at chemist stores. As if its a loaded gun or dope you’re asking for! That applies to condoms as well…but that’s another story…

What is with the hush-hush mentality? While I don’t think I need to announce to the world that I am chumming at any given point of time, I definitely don’t think its something I actively need to hide. And really, if you decide to eat in separate utensils and steer clear of the kitchen/temple, you aren’t doing a great job of hiding it any way.

It is just a natural phenomenon that leads to reproduction and it should be treated as normal. It is ok if some feel embarrassed to talk about it, just like young boys might, regarding nightfall. But crowding the phenomenon with  religious practices which just perpetuate more subjugation of women is a complete NO.

A teenager, in one of my classes shared with me that in their community, all sanitary towels had to be collected and at the end of the cycle, taken to an open ground and burnt. Yes, burnt, as they carry evil and could serve as fodder to people practicing black magic…To think that this is just one more way of discriminating against females is no exaggeration. Because that is exactly what it leads to. Girls growing up, believing that they’re “dirty” and that its like a curse to have a period. It teaches them to be ashamed of something that nature has given them.

Really, we should have evolved long ago.

Responses

I never thought that even menstruation had prejudices attached to it. I remember in 8th standard, a female classmate telling me, “Girls go through a lot of physical changes quickly. You know, like um…growing tall. And there’s something more…” When I insisted, she went, “When you grow up, your wife will tell you!” ;P

I thought girls are actually proud of periods and love the confusing-boys and making-in-jokes opportunities it gives them! Maybe boys are more cool about it that girls!

me: go away from here…u’re too young :D first get married and ask ur wife ;)

I’ve always been fascinated by the fact that when women hang out too much, their (our? :) periods get in sync with the others.

Boarding school meant entire dorms would be PMSing at the same time. Fun bond :)

But tell me something, today is every woman blogger down, or this is random ESP?? Why is chumming suddenly such a hot topic? Long live tampons, anyway.

me: just saw posts so thought of sharing my opinion too…plus its definitely a cause worth championing!

I did go through the big celebration thing when I had my first period. I enjoyed the attention and the gifts until I was informed by the grandmother that I will have to stop wearing skimpy clothes and hanging out with boys. She even tried to make me sit in a separate room and all but I was too rebellious for that I guess. Now, period means nothing more than a few days of PMS and zits. But yay!to all you girls for the posts on the unmentionable M word. :)

me: oh the zits yes…I get them too!

Bleh. Cannot be bothered, am quite fine with telling folks that I’m “not well… am female”, or “on my period” if they’re close enough.
Grandmother yelled at me for touching the puja almirah while on my period. Bitch.
Was discussing the need of wings on pads with boyfriend today, heh.

I wonder why the endometrium has to go OUT every month. Is it disposable or something? :P .
And yeah, could live without the hormone rush that is currently fucking bigtime with the head. Could also live without the sore muscles. I guess being able to be a mom is worth it?
(Umm… sorry. Have slept about 3 hours in the last 24. Make that 4 including siesta. Can’t make sense)

me: LOL!!!! I guess if there is no fertilization, it is disposable!

Is it a coincidence that I wrote in my last post how much I hate being a woman when m chumming?!?! So a woman I know once told me tat if I love being a woman I should ‘enjoy’ this too..Well.. whatever!

But yeah, going to chemist asking for a Whisper Ultra is embarassing, more cuz of the funny look the guys at the chemist’s shop gives. I always pick it up from a department store where I dont hafta ‘ask’ for it!!!

And even if ur open to discussing it, people listening to it might not be equally comfortable. So I refrain from talking unless with someone close.

me: Chemists will stare even if u were to ask for medicines for RTIs/UTIs?STDs or condoms…don’t let that bother!

my family practiced degregation actively at the same time telling me it was normal..talk about mixed messages

me: i can imagine…mostly, its “normal” is the message if u decide to make a big deal…and becomes a big deal if u decide to go easy!

Segregation oops

this must confirm the prejudice..an embarrassed rambler trying to skip the post

me: don’t worry! as long as we’re all open to discussion and questioning our own beliefs

I was telling MM the same.. I still feel very prejudiced… Its more about your comfort..

Mum always discouraged me to use cotton napkins, as according to her, if you dispose them in the bins, the dogs and pigs eat it. Eeeeyuck! What is her point anyways…???

i guess having an older sister helps…u dont make a big deal out of it!!

i got first hand information from my di too…and coming from an open minded family, i was thought to laugh away the old wives tales…
its really sad for people who believe in the ‘its a evil thing’ crap!

It does seem like a coincidence that the whole blogosphere seems to be talking about chumming at just the time that I am chumming!

Talking about buying sanitary pads, the first time I had to do it was when I moved to a hostel. (Before that, it was always mum who bought them for us.) And I must admit, I was embarassed as hell. I was 18 then and forced my friend and senior in college to buy them for me because the shopkeeper happened to be a guy. I now realise the shopkeeper couldn’t have cared less if I was buying large or XL STs as long as it got him the bucks… Now I worry about other stuff - like buying OTC pregnancy test kits ;)

me: LOL

Ahhhh… my all time favourtie topic to get all het p over. My place we still hafta follow the segregation crap but since I live away I don’t think of it anymore :)
Oh and in Kerala, apparently it’s common in the rural areas to burn used napkins because they believe there is a kind of snake which comes and wraps itself around menstruating women if it smells the odor… what it does after giving them a hug I don’t know…

And it IS kind of weird how females living in close vicinity tend to have their period around the same time… and as another blogger pointed out, PMS seems to be something we women unleash on the males only… when was the last time any girl got all weepy or furious at another woman for pure PMS related stress??

End point? Women need TLC when chumming and they need it lots… everything else is just plain, unadulterated bullshit.

“What is with the hush-hush mentality?”

Well..even the sanitary napkin is called “Whisper”!!!!

Linked up to you!

You use the word chums as well!! :D
I comemented on MM’s post - i agree - its discrimination and its not “dirty” or “impure”
It never fails to piss me off - all this second-rate treatment… I should do a post to get it off my mind!

amen!!!!

Seriously, you go girl! Well said :-)

Folks just need to get over it! I wish I had known my monthly periods had such evil powers. I could think of so many people to destroy with my powers :-P *HEHAHAHOHEHE* (my evil laugh)

Anybody here to shed some light on how I can create evil power?

It cracks me up when these chemists whip out a black panni and procceed to discreetly stuff the sanitary pad packet into it. Haha!!

I’ve also heard about black magic being done on a woman’s cast off napkin. Wonder if they do that on used condoms too!!?!

Menstruation is a fantastic biological process which is conducted with utmost precision and co-ordination of a lot of body parts. Its more like a conveyor belt of activities that happens in the woman’s body.. its actually so amazing.

Its also sad that such an amazing thing has to be treated in such a cavalier and dreaded fashion by our culture.. I just do not understand how a woman on her periods becomes impure enough not to do puja or enter a temple.. beats me completely.

me: spoken like a true doctor :D

I was amazed to discover when I arrived in France that the poor girl who is having her first period is supposed to be slapped in the face by her mother!

In Christian countries periods are the punishment because of Eve’s sin of tempting Adam with an apple. The pain of child birth being the ultimate punishment!

When I was a teenager I suffered terribly with my periods and was constantly told that it was all in the mind and not to make a fuss. I’m so pleased that my daughter was treated symaphetically and given medication that worked.

As usual you’ve written an interesting and thought provoking post!

me: what u mentioned about the christian countries is news to me! Thanks for sharing!

Ok…First things first. “A friend told me that when she was in school, which was a convent, one of the nuns made the sign of the cross every time she passed a girl who was chumming…”

HOW could the nun make out if a girl was chumming? And what when she herself was chumming? Being a nun doesn’t make periods evaporate, does it? *confused*

me: i am sure in hostel type settings…nuns probably know when girls have their period…i don’t really know…

Secondly, there are some “educated” women in the city who act like periods are something terrible. A friend’s mom who was a PhD in some subject in Biology (hahahahaha) did not allow her to use sanitary napkins, because, “when you throw them, the trash reaches a jungle, and a snake might go over it and die.” Eh? WHAT? *confused again*

I really wonder how much further backwards we are going to ‘progress’. It all seems bleak to me. :( All I can say is, I’m thankful that some of us are fortunate enough to grow up in sensible, mentally educated home.

As usual, great post!

[...] mom was inspired by that one. I followed up with my thoughts. And Lavs responded. Chandni wrapped it up. I am sure more will follow. There you have it. Say the word menstruation and you have a bunch of [...]

@anjiknut. excellent. will not move to France. Likely to slap anyone who slaps me!

@Moo: You know - i am vague about this but i am sure it was the nuns who told me not to come in to the chapel when i was chumming. could be wrong. its been ages. silly nutjobs. do tell me if you ever find out why the snake that goes over the pad dies. we once had a dog a who ripped into a used one from the dustbin and spent the day gathering bloody cotton all over the old house and garden. that is the worst i can imagine if a pad lands in a jungle.

First time commenting here. Just wanted to add my thoughts on why pads are burned in some places. Many towns in India do not have a proper disposal system - pads and other trash are thrown on empty plots of land. Can get picked up by scavanging dogs or pigs or small children (yes, I’ve seen that). So burning them would definitely be a better disposal option.

me: thanks for that info veena, I really had no idea that this could be a reason. The only girl who spoke to me about this method of disposal said that their family believed it carries “evil” and hence ahs to be destroyed…

agree!! i hate the thought that something that is part of our natural body and what actually aids us in bringing life into this world is considered evil and dirty - my mother used to impose the same thoughts on me when I was a teenager and I followed them blindly until I found the sense to ask - “Why?”. (This is despitre living in a western country for at the time a good 14 years) I don’t believe in isolation at all.

me: ditto!

hey linked your post. commenting now only. i guess in today’s world periods is a non issue now…why bother abt announcing!!

Ahhhh. My girl. Finally an easygoing post… :)

You’re right. Having periods is as normal as breathing, and if one doesn’t shout “Look ma, I’m breathing!” or hide that fact, one is silly to advertise/hide the menstruation.

We likey. A lot :)

me: :D

Had posted a while ago and my connection conked off. Periods and PMS can be a pain for some, but no reason to segregate or be considered impure, in my opinion.
My husband is much younger than his sisters, so he was pretty clueless and we’d have major battles when I was PMSing early in our marriage. My sons’ generation is so clued in that now every time they deal with an argumentative female, it’s easy to dismiss her as having PMS. We women just can’t win. Bah.

[...] an interesting topic on in the blogworld right now. Some posts on the issue. To sum it up, there’s obviously a lot of annoyance expressed when women are [...]

Wonderful post and on a topic close to my heart. There are some girls who don’t even buy their own lingerie…usually their moms or bolder (elder or younger) sisters buy for them!! And the stupid custom of standing outside the temple just cuz ur chumming is so hypocritical in a place where we worship Shakti and celebrate Navratri.

me: true! hypocricy is the word

women are impure during periods. everybody knows this. why are you fighting nature. men and women is not equal. accept your impurity, pray to god to make you pure. why do you want to spread your bad luck and make everyone sad?

all you modern women are the same. you think you know better than our forefathers. if you cannot even take the three to five days of discipline, how will you have children?

linked all 3 period posts

Take it as a pride… The beauty of being a women is that she menstruates and has the wonderful gift of being able to reproduce… There is no need to be embarrassed at the looks of the chemist guy where you go to buy sanitary napkins…

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories